
Final Report for Practical Work of the Course ENGG1300 of Group C9 — 3/5
Table 1. Compaison of the overlapping and side-by-side connection methods.
Aspect Overlapping Side-by-side
Load Distribution Across all layers via friction and interlocking Concentrated at the joint
Strength ∝ number of layers × strength of one layer ∝ adhesive shear strength
Stiffness High due to composite action Low due to tape not structurally integrated
downward vertical component and horizontal component
directed away from the centre at the end of the slanted
members. When the horizontal component is larger than
the friction between the major members and the ground, the
members would start to slide away from the centre, which
would lead to most of the load being redistributed to the
central member.
To restrain the horizontal movements of the members,
the group has designed a restraining piece. The piece was
made of several layers of continuous newspapers folded
into a belt-like shape, which was then wrapped around the
base.
Due to its continuous nature, the full potential of the
paper fibres could be utilised to provide tensile strength.
It was expected that when the members start to slide, the
restraining piece would be able to counteract with its tensile
strength.
3. First Trial
The model for the first trial was built with the following
specifications:
1. Weight and Height: Within the limits.
2.
Newspaper Used: Mainly the Sing Tao Daily (
星島
日報).
3. Adhesive Tape Used: Scotch Magic Tape (3M).
4.
Design: The supporting members did not observe
the design as described in section 2.2. However,
those members did not have significant impact on
the analysis of the model.
The model is shown in Figure 3a.
3.1 Results
The first model failed to withstand a minimum load of
500 N
. The model was able to withstand a load of
480 N
before deformation occurred. It was observed that buckling
occurred at the major members at a short instant after
the load was applied (as shown in Figure 3b). Of all the
members, the three external slanted members were the first
to buckle, while the central vertical member experienced
the most deformation.
3.2 Rationale of Failure
After inspection of the failed model, the group has identified
three major reasons that contributed to the failure of the
model.
3.2.1 Low Density of the Major Members
All of the major members in the model were fabricated
without aid of any tools. The newspaper pipes were rolled
by hand, leaving large gaps between the layers of newspapers.
This resulted in a low density of the major members.
To quantitatively analyse this issue, the gap-interleaving
members can be approximated as a hollow cylinder of inner
radius
r
and outer radius
R
and compared with a solid
cylinder of radius
R
. The moments of inertia of the two
models are
I
hollow
=
π
64
(D
4
−d
4
)
and
I
solid
=
π
4
D
4
. It is
trivial to see that
I
hollow
< I
solid
. By Equation 1, the critical
load of the hollow cylinder is less than that of the solid
cylinder. This shows that the hollow cylinder is more prone
to buckling.
Furthermore, during fabrication, the newspapers might
have been rolled unevenly, resulting in folds and wrinkles
on the surface of the pipes. This further reduce the stability
of the major members.
3.2.2
Presence of Weak Points at Paper-to-Tape Junctions
While applying the adhesive tape on the pipes, the surfaces
of the pipes were not thoroughly covered, resulting in surfaces
that were exposed to air. This led to inconsistent surface
stiffness as surfaces with adhesive tapes are stiffer than those
without. When under compressive pressure, the joints at
which surfaces with discontinuous stiffness meet are prone
to buckling.
3.2.3
Imbalance of Load Distribution Due to Mismatched
Lengths of the Slanted Members
The group was not rigorous in measuring the lengths of
the slanted members. Prior to the first trial, the group
has noticed that the structure was unable to support itself
evenly on all columns, and that one of the slanted members
remained not in contact with the ground. This resulted in
an imbalance of load distribution. During compression,
the stress was concentrated on the central member and the
slanted members that were in contact with the ground, while
the remaining member acted as a Zero Force Member. As
a result, some of the members were subjected to stress
that exceeded the designed limit and buckled, which is
consistent with the observation.
3.3 Measures Taken for Improvement
In order to address the issues identified in the first trial,
the group has taken the following measures to improve the
model in fabrication of the model for the final trial.
3.3.1
Rolling the Members with Tools to Increase Density
and Avoid Defects
The group has used thin cylindrical wooden rods to assist
in rolling the newspapers into pipes. The rods were placed
on the newspapers while rolling, such that the newspapers
could bind tightly and uniformly, reducing gaps between
layers and wrinkles on the surface. The rod was then
removed after the pipe was rolled. This method streamlined
pipe production and improved the strength of the major
members.